Oya vs Firecrawl: extract public web data or run signed-in workflows.
Both offer browser interaction and MCP support, yet they start from different jobs. Compare whether your pipeline scrapes public pages into structured data or signs in to portals that require sealed credentials, human takeover and deterministic replay.
Criteria from the comparison below.
Start with whether the page is public or behind a staff login.
Public web collection and authenticated portal execution carry different requirements. Map out login handling, two-factor steps, repeat execution cost and compliance obligations before picking one stack.
Compare the requirements that follow from that task.
Look at agent connections, reuse of completed work, deployment and human intervention. If protected health information (PHI) is involved, check the covered edition and Business Associate Agreement (BAA).
Check the published differences.
The table below uses the linked vendor pages and their stated review date. “Not stated” means the pages reviewed did not say; it does not establish that a capability is absent.
| Oya | Firecrawl | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is built for | Browser and control plane for signed-in agent workflows: desktop app, Oya Cloud, self-hosted, MCP and CDP | Web data API (scrape, crawl, map, search) plus /interact Browser Sandbox, MCP server and local Rust CLI |
| Replays a finished task with no model | Yes: playbooks, and the agent repairs only a step that moved | Not stated |
| Replay is standard Playwright you own | Yes: every playbook is a readable Playwright module that runs on any Chromium browser over CDP | Not stated: /interact accepts prompts or Playwright code inside its sandbox |
| Model never sees passwords | Passwords and TOTP seeds are sealed and never shown to the model | Not stated |
| A person can take over live | Watch live, take over, hand back | Interactive Live View on Firecrawl Cloud Browser Sandbox |
| Runs in your own infrastructure | Enterprise edition on Docker, ECS, GCP or Kubernetes, with a BAA; community edition free up to 5 browsers | Self-hostable apps/api (AGPL-3.0) and firecrawl-local Rust binary |
| SOC 2 | Type I report issued; Type II audit in progress | Type II on all plans; Zero Data Retention on Enterprise |
| Signs a BAA for HIPAA work | Yes: HIPAA mode on Oya Cloud (BAA on request) or self-hosted in your own cloud | Not stated |
| Audit trail of agent and person actions | Append-only and hash-chained; every read of ePHI audited; kept six years in HIPAA mode | Not stated |
| Free tier, then first paid plan | Free desktop app and 1 cloud browser hour; $500 a month for 100 hours | Free (1,000 credits, 2 concurrent); Hobby $16/mo annual ($19 monthly), Standard $83/mo, Growth $333/mo, Scale $599/mo, Enterprise custom |
Choose Oya when
- Agents must sign in to portals with sealed passwords and TOTP seeds that the model never sees.
- You want finished browser workflows exported as standalone Playwright playbooks that replay with no model.
- You need an append-only audit trail, self-hosting in your own network, or HIPAA compliance with a signed BAA on Oya Cloud or the enterprise edition.
Choose Firecrawl when
- Your primary job is scraping, crawling, mapping or searching public websites into clean Markdown or JSON.
- You want credit-based API pricing starting with a free tier (1,000 credits) and low-entry paid plans ($16/mo annual Hobby).
- You want SOC 2 Type II or Enterprise Zero Data Retention for web extraction without needing a signed HIPAA BAA.
How teams pair them cleanly.
Oya does not route browsers through Firecrawl. Teams that need both public web research and authenticated portal actions often use Firecrawl for bulk scraping and Oya for signed-in, audited browser workflows and HIPAA-covered workloads.
Test the fit with your own work.
Use the comparison to shortlist an approach, then evaluate it against a representative workflow.
Sources
What this page says about other companies comes from their own public pages, read on 2026-11-20. Vendors change their pages; check the source before you rely on a cell.
Bring one working automation into your project, then try it with the next set of inputs.
Start buildingQuestions
What is the main difference between Oya Browser and Firecrawl?
Firecrawl is a web data API built for scraping, crawling, mapping and searching websites, with an /interact Browser Sandbox for scripted or prompted sessions. Oya Browser is a desktop, cloud and self-hosted browser built for signed-in agent tasks: sealed passwords and TOTP, live human takeover, standalone Playwright playbooks that replay with no model, an append-only audit trail, and HIPAA compliance with a BAA on Oya Cloud and the enterprise edition.
Does Firecrawl state HIPAA compliance or a BAA?
Firecrawl states SOC 2 Type II on all plans and Zero Data Retention on Enterprise; HIPAA compliance and a BAA were not stated on the Firecrawl pricing and documentation pages reviewed on 2026-11-20. Oya signs BAAs for HIPAA mode on Oya Cloud and the enterprise edition.
Can I self-host Oya or Firecrawl?
Firecrawl provides a self-hostable API under AGPL-3.0 and a firecrawl-local Rust binary. Oya self-hosts as the source-available community edition (free up to 5 browsers) or the enterprise edition on Docker, ECS, GCP or Kubernetes with a BAA.
Does Oya export Playwright code I can run elsewhere?
Yes. Every finished Oya playbook exports as a readable Playwright module that runs on any Chromium browser over CDP, with no model in the loop.
Can I self-host a HIPAA-compliant agentic browser?
Yes, with the enterprise edition: it runs on Docker, ECS, GCP or Kubernetes, comes with a BAA, and keeps HIPAA workloads in your own infrastructure. Write to sales@getoya.ai. The source-available community edition self-hosts too, without the HIPAA offering. Every playbook exports as Playwright code you keep.